What the evidence establishes
CLAIM 01YIMBY reported on October 8, 2025 that Concern Logan at 467 Logan Street had a 25-apartment public lottery with applications due December 5, 2025. Brownstoner reported the same offering and deadline on November 11, followed by its credited Brooklyn Paper republication on November 18.
Scope: 467 Logan Street, East New York, Brooklyn · 2025-10-08 – 2025-12-05
Assessment: SUPPORTEDAll three inspected bodies support the bounded reporting sequence. Their publication dates do not establish the lottery’s precise launch day or first occupancy.
What is not established: The actual offering remains secondary-attributed. Conflicting percentage and supportive-unit wording is not resolved by repetition; the two Schneps pages are one editorial chain.
CLAIM 02The state packet prepared for the September 8, 2022 HTFC meeting described Concern Logan as a proposed 66-apartment Brooklyn development including one superintendent apartment, with 40 supportive apartments and 25 other income-restricted apartments.
Scope: 2602 Pitkin Avenue, Brooklyn · 2022-09-08 – 2022-09-08
Assessment: SUPPORTEDThe complete original project description expressly distinguishes staff and resident categories. Meeting materials alone do not establish approval or final delivery.
What is not established: The allocation is a 2022 proposal, not a confirmed final 2025 allocation. Later media wording differs and the original lottery body was unreadable.
Limits and open questions
The actual offering remains secondary-attributed. Conflicting percentage and supportive-unit wording is not resolved by repetition; the two Schneps pages are one editorial chain.
The allocation is a 2022 proposal, not a confirmed final 2025 allocation. Later media wording differs and the original lottery body was unreadable.
The state plan specifies 40 supportive apartments and one staff apartment; Brownstoner later says 41 supportive apartments and its copy calls the entire non-lottery remainder supportive. Final categories were not inspected, so a later change versus an error is unresolved. YIMBY also supplies inconsistent AMI percentages.
The operator’s 2024 completion field and 2025 lottery reporting concern different milestones; neither establishes first move-in or full occupancy.